Powered by Blogger

Monday, June 05, 2023

Merit = Prejudice

 I'm in a diversity workshop for librarians and almost immediately one of the older white women asserts that we shouldn't announce the race or gender of the author when we promote author talks, because we don't do that for white, heterosexual authors. And we should read books based on their MERIT. This is my absolutely favorite fall-back position of white privilege - now that others are getting attention and being seen as valid, now they want all the choices to be based on merit. The implication is that we don't have to make up for the past, when nonwhites were never rewarded for their merit.

Of course, no one pushes back because we don't do that here - the discussion moves on after her comments without any of the facilitators responding.

She is making the case against her argument in the way she is phrasing it. White heterosexual authors have been massively overrepresented in libraries for centuries. You don't have to tell the audience the author is white and heterosexual, because they always are.

We announce when they aren't because we want to alert anyone who would like to know there will be representation from other types of authors. And to acknowledge that we have made assumptions in the past that are not going to be made anymore.

Sunday, June 04, 2023

Aggravating guest

This is so weird: the last time I got a snitty review like this, I had listened to the guest just vomit his opinions onto me for a couple of hours. The exact same thing happened with this guest - I sat there listening to her bloviate for a couple of hours in the evening, she went into the bedroom, left first thing in the morning, and then her review was kind of obnoxious. Why on earth would you stay in someone's house knowing they have a cat if you're allergic to cats? I mean, I'm sorry the cat was bugging her, but no one else has said the cat was a problem, and other guests have managed to close the door. I was up very late (the light in my bedroom was on), she could have said something to me instead of just posting a mean review.

But honestly, it's the bitching about the house being small that really annoys me. My listing is CHEAP and the description is very accurate, with lots of photos. There are many other listings in Grand Forks that are just a little more money. If you want more space, a bigger bed, and a separate bathroom, PAY THE MONEY. Don't stay in the small, cheap place, and then bitch about it being small.