Essay for Laura's Pride Guide, 2016 (their 25th anniversary):
Television
Then and Now
Who remembers what they were doing 25 years ago? For some of
you reading this, you were toddling around in diapers. But for many, like me,
we vividly recall those halcyon days, when we were spreading our wings in a
blustery world, testing them to see if they could hold our weight.
Television was a wasteland in 1991, if you were looking for
gay role models. Soap, with Billy
Crystal’s Jodie, had ended a decade earlier. Ellen was 3 years down the road, and Will and Grace was still 7 years away.
What we had was Roseanne.
In 1991, Sandra Bernhard joined the cast as one of the first openly lesbian
characters to have a recurring role on a network television sitcom. The show’s
popularity did not suffer from the introduction of Nancy Bartlett, and the
acceptance of her character emboldened Roseanne. The show remained among the
top 5 shows in the nation, according to the Nielsen ratings, through the middle
of the decade, giving Roseanne the ability to include more gay themes and
events in her show. The famous kiss with Mariel Hemingway didn’t happen until
1994, but it was followed closely by Martin Mull’s wedding to Fred Willis the
following year. The network had balked
at the kiss, but Roseanne threatened to move to another network when NBC said
they wouldn’t air the episode.
The presence of Sandra Bernhard’s Nancy and Martin Mull’s
Leon were a refreshing change from gay, lesbian, and transgender characters,
who more generally appeared on television as prostitutes, murder victims, or
murderers, or, as the 1980s wound down, as noble/tragic victims of AIDS. (It
would be another couple of decades before the existence of bisexual people was
acknowledged in any way on TV shows.)
The Golden Girls, a
perennial ratings winner, ended in 1992. It occasionally featured a gay
character, including Blanche’s brother, Clayton, portrayed by Monte Markham,
who eventually got married in an episode airing in 1991. The show was generally
gay friendly, probably because openly gay Marc Cherry, who went on to create Desperate Housewives, was a producer and
writer of the show.
Similarly, Designing
Women, another popular sitcom which hit its ratings peak in 1991, featured
a gay character, Anthony Bouvier, portrayed by Menasch Taylor. Antony’s
character occasionally wore women’s clothing, through various tortured plot
twists, but otherwise his orientation was only expressed through the
character’s stereotypical portrayal, rather than having a romantic or sexual
life of his own. Tangentially, the show won a GLAAD Media Award in 1991 for the
episode “Suzanne Goes Looking for a Friend,” in which Suzanne discovers that
her former pageant friend, Eugenia, portrayed by Karen Kopins, is a lesbian.
Drama series did not do as well as Roseanne, in terms of presenting fully formed gay characters. The
popular baby boomer drama, thirtysomething,
which had featured an HIV positive character, ended in 1991, as did the night
time soap opera Dallas. (Dallas
didn’t have any gay characters, I just included it so you’d realize it’s been
gone for 25 years.)
Melrose Place, created
by Darren Starr (who later would develop Sex
and the City from Candace Bushnell’s popular NY Observer columns), included a gay character, Matt Fielding,
portrayed by Doug Savant, and began in 1992. Critics continually complained
about the lack of romantic, and especially sexual, life of Matt, in a show that
emphasized both for its straight characters. The show admitted that it wanted
to avoid backlash from conservative activist groups who notoriously organized
product boycotts whenever a TV show challenged their moral standards.
LA Law had a
lesbian lawyer (C.J. Lamb, portrayed by Amanda Donohoe) on staff in the middle
of the show’s 8 season run (which happened to straddle 1991), but she
disappeared after a lesbian kiss generally acknowledged as a publicity stunt
during ratings sweeps week. Sadly, the show initiated somewhat of a trend of
featuring a kiss between a straight woman and a lesbian character, done for
publicity value only.
Fast forward 25 years. We no longer have to scour the TV
schedule for the occasional gay character or gay issue reference. Now we regularly
have entire programs devoted to us (HBO’s Looking
just finished a successful 2 season run, a 2-hour series finale will be aired
in July). Indeed, we have an entire network (Here).
Perhaps even more impressive is that popular programs
directed at every conceivable audience now include fully developed LGBTQ
characters without fear of backlash.
Programs on network television (Modern Family on ABC), on cable (American Horror Story on FX), and on
alternate services like Netflix (Orange
is the New Black) and Amazon (Transparent)
feature LGBTQ characters and address LGBTQ concerns unabashedly,
comprehensively, and with compassion.
Shows aimed at youth audiences, such as Glee (which just completed 6 seasons on Fox), The Fosters (whose 4th season on ABC Family starts this month), and
Faking It (which just finished 3
successful seasons on MTV) increasingly have honest, positive, and complex
presentations of LGBTQ lives.
Even historical dramas manage to showcase LGBTQ concerns,
such as Downton Abbey showing a gay
man in the early 20th century attempting a damaging “cure” for his
homosexuality. The massively popular Game
of Thrones includes LGBTQ characters among its cast of thousands, without
concern about the sensitivities of its straight viewers.
Perhaps most encouraging, and, most surprising, is the
runaway hit, Empire, a drama on Fox about
a family-run music business, based loosely on King Lear, and, as producer Lee
Daniels admits, borrowing from the 1980s primetime soap, Dynasty. The show features a Who’s Who of today’s African American
acting royalty, including Oscar nominated Terrance Howard as the patriarch,
Lucious, and the indelible (and Oscar and Emmy nominated) Taraji P. Nelson as
the matriarch, Cookie, along with a string of famous guest stars. The African
American community has been much slower to accept their LGBTQ brethren, so
having one of the three sons on the show be openly gay was a bold, unexpected,
and welcome situation. The show begins
its 3rd season this fall.
Comparing the scant offering of the bygone era of the 1990s with the cornucopia of characters in today’s entertainment landscape almost boggles the mind. Feminists like to say “we haven’t come a long way and we’re not babies” in response to the famous Virginia Slims cigarette advertising campaign. But looking back at the progress that has occurred in our societal acceptance of LBGTQ people as measured by their portrayal in in popular television culture, I can’t help feeling that we were only half right.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home